Sunday Morning Quarterback: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Around SBN: Big 12 Final Box Score Rankings Bar-right-arrows



SMQ Readers' Choice Awards: The Edwards-Fitzgerald Award

Some corporate entities and clubs that seem to exist for no reason outside of doling out trophies at lavish dinners his morning, the Downtown Athletic Club of SMQ introduces an ongoing feature of the next couple weeks: the prestigious SMQ Readers' Choice Awards for excellence in whatever quirky field crosses his mind, with winners selected by you. Results will be announced sometime later this month, whenever clever categories run dry. Everyone who stops by is encouraged to participate by clicking the appropriate circle in the "Poll" section of the righthand sidebar.

If you have any award ideas for SMQ, please leave them in the comment section. Spam-deflection means you'll have to register, but it couldn't be easier.

Today:

The Edwards-Fitzgerald Award
Presented to the best player at whom to throw the ball as high as possible as often as possible
In the tradition of the most eye-opening of the new breed of big play receiver as acrobatic,  boxing out, rebounding power forward, the winner of the venerable Edwards-Fitzgerald is one whose hands and lank in traffic mark him as uncoverable highlight reel out of defensive coordinators' nightmares.

The nominees are:

Marcus Monk Arkansas
Averaged just shy of 20 yards per catch and scored 11 touchdowns in an offense designed specifically to hide its junior college quarterbacking and that eventually decided it was just as well off letting the running backs and whoever chuck it around. All gravy to Monk: he had a catch of at least 15 yards in every game and of 35 or more in eight. Even teams who limited him - hello, Auburn - were burned at some point.

Calvin Johnson Georgia Tech
Mutant talent shattered career bests in catches, yards and touchdowns, in only slightly more conventional fashion than his first two seasons. Occasionally slowed - Clemson, North Carolina, Georgia - but even when his offense forgot about him, or his quarterback couldn't put the ball in a catchable position for even the borderline suprnatural, everybody freaked about his not touching it. That's something in itself. Lowest yards per catch on this list.

Greg Carr Florida State
Well, Jeff Bowden thought so, at least. Six-six leaper's 11 touchdowns on 30 catches must be among the best touch/score ratios anywhere.

Adarius Bowman Oklahoma State
Didn't see him play, but had one game with 13 catches for 300 yards and four touchdowns, against a team playing in a bowl contest this month. Six-four sophomore had seven touchdowns otherwise on about 20 per catch.

Dwayne Jarrett USC
Missed parts of the year, everyone forgot about him, before he eats Notre Dame alive and everybody checks to see if his injury-deflated stats justify another all-America bid. In terms of a talent for "boxing out" for the ball, remember his second touchdown at Notre Dame, and moments like this:


Pete Carroll studies closely for his Edwards-Fitzgerald vote

Maurice Purify Nebraska
Raw junior college behemoth terrorized every Big XII foe in one fashion or another: six touchdowns on 29 catches in-conference, few of them sizzling lopes into the open field. SMQ is certain Texas and Missouri can vouch for him.

Those are the candidates. SMQ has the first vote, and casts it in favor of Monk. The rest is up to you.

0 recs | Comment 4 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Hate to Kill a Nole Here...
...but Carr's ratio is so high because he can't run any other precise routes, and his hands aren't all that great. If you think Jeffy sent long balls his way too often this season, you should hear the fanbase howling for the fade on every other play...

by Halleck T on Dec 6, 2006 11:21 AM EST   0 recs

Sounds fine for this award...
This isn't about running precise routes. It's about towering over DBs and coming down with jump balls even while blanketed. I'm not nominating Carr for an all-America team. I know he's not a good all-around guy, but he's a big, lanky, basketball-type leaper who secondaries have to pay inordinate attention to.

by SMQ on Dec 6, 2006 11:28 AM EST   0 recs

Fair enough...
But I feel like defenses have to account for guys like Jarrett and Johnson all over the field, whereas you don't have to pay attention to Carr until the red zone. But if you're looking for one guy to leap in the back corner of the end zone and come down with it (and nothing else) Carr's your man.

by Halleck T on Dec 6, 2006 2:12 PM EST   0 recs

Purify...
I'll vote for Monk, too.

Not sure about Purify. He was a solid acrobat-type guy, but not the towering deep ball behometh that Limas Sweed was. Limas caught jump balls, streak balls, balls at his shoe tips. Would give him the nod over Purify.

Anyway, moot point. I still vote Monk.

by PB @ BON on Dec 6, 2006 4:27 PM EST   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

College Football Coverage

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Tucsonroyal_small
Question: What percentage of teams win based on the Vegas point spread?
Javierbardem-no-country-for-old-men_small
It doesn't have to be Sunday to talk about the sham that is the BCS!
Small
OU 42 UT28
Small
College Football Question: Penn State University
Small
Tiger Walk
Small
USC Song Girls
Small
College Football Question: The Big East
Small
College Football Question: Thursday Night Football
Small
The New Location for SMQ!
Rockmnation_small
Beyond the Box Score: SEC Edition (Part Two)

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Site Meter